When Compassion Cannot Choose a Side

When Compassion Cannot Choose a Side

This morning, something happened that left me contemplating the nature of life, suffering, compassion, and the strange contradictions of our existence.

I had just turned on my electric stove when a tiny fly (size of a fruit fly) came flying by and landed on the hot plate. Within seconds, I noticed one of its wings beginning to burn. I immediately used the cloth I was holding to move it off the hot plate, and it fell to the floor.

At first, I couldn’t find it. I searched around until I finally spotted it, then carefully lifted it with a tissue onto a piece of paper to see if it was still alive. What I saw broke my heart. Its tiny body appeared dried out and so fragile that it looked almost as though it had broken into two pieces. I could hardly believe how much damage could happen to such a tiny living being in just a few moments.

What disturbed me most wasn’t simply the possibility that it had died. It was imagining what it might have gone through in those few seconds on that burning surface. How much pain might that tiny creature have experienced? I will never know. But the thought that it might have suffered so terribly, even for those brief moments, was deeply painful.

Just moments earlier, it had been flying around, completely unaware of what awaited it. And suddenly, there it was, so still and fragile. It left me wondering how much suffering unfolds in this world, every moment, in lives so small that we rarely even notice them.

Every morning, I spend time feeding the birds that visit my balcony. I prepare their food, replace their water, watch them eat and bathe, and do whatever I can to keep them safe. Their presence brings me tremendous joy. Some arrive before I have even put out their food, waiting in their favorite spots. Others fly in with such enthusiasm that they seem surprised to discover the feeders aren’t ready yet. These little moments have become such a beautiful part of my everyday life.

On one hand, I find myself doing everything I can to nurture and protect life. On the other, I am reminded how fragile that very life is, how unexpectedly suffering can arise, and how little control we sometimes have over what happens. What a strange universe we live in.

We celebrate birth, mourn death, seek happiness, resist pain, satisfy hunger, and struggle with loss. Yet none of these experiences remain. Happiness passes. Pain passes. Hunger returns. Fulfillment fades. Every experience we try so hard to hold on to eventually changes.

Impermanence is not an occasional interruption of life. It is the very nature of life.

The Contradiction of Compassion

But my contemplation did not end with that little fly. It reminded me of something I have often observed. Tiny insects gathering around lights, sometimes even candle flames, and dying. Their lives are so fragile, and it takes so little for them to come to an end.

And even if they escape such dangers, their lives are vulnerable in so many other ways. A bird can catch an insect and eat it in an instant. What marks the end of one life becomes nourishment for another.

That thought brought me back to the birds I care for every morning. Here I was, heartbroken over the suffering of a tiny fly, while knowing that birds themselves sometimes survive by eating creatures just as small. And yet, those very birds are equally vulnerable. Just as an insect can become food for a bird, a bird can become food for another creature.

And suddenly, I found myself looking at the same cycle of life from different sides.

What about the hawk?

The hawk is hungry too. Perhaps it has little ones waiting in a nest. It is not hunting out of hatred or cruelty. It is simply trying to survive. If I were raising that hawk instead, caring for it and worrying about whether it had eaten enough, wouldn’t I want it to find food?

And there lies a contradiction that I find extraordinarily difficult to reconcile.

The little bird wants to live. The hawk needs to eat. One life struggles to escape death while another struggles to escape hunger.

What sustains one life may destroy another. And when I try to feel compassion for both, I find myself unable to choose a side. How do I wish for the survival of the bird without wishing hunger upon the hawk? How do I care for both when their very needs seem to oppose each other?

When Love Becomes Fear

The more I think about it, the more I realize that this contradiction is not merely between the hawk and the bird. It is also within me.

When I look at the little bird, I feel love. That love makes me protective. The moment I imagine a hawk approaching, the same love becomes fear. Fear of losing something precious to me. And if the hawk were to take that bird, my fear and grief could easily become anger toward the hawk.

Isn’t that extraordinary?

The very love that made me want to nurture one creature could become the reason I resent another.

Same love. Three different faces: care, fear, anger. The hawk hasn’t changed. My relationship with it has.

I am reminded of Guruji’s teachings about how the same underlying energy can manifest in different forms. Love, when entangled with attachment, can express itself as fear. Fear, when intensified, can become anger or even hatred. What appears to be opposing emotions may arise from the same underlying energy, shaped by our attachments and perceptions.

And isn’t this what happens in our human relationships too? The love that brings us our deepest happiness can also become the source of jealousy, possessiveness, resentment, and suffering. Sometimes, the more deeply we love, the more intensely we fear losing what we love.

The suffering doesn’t come from loving deeply, but from the fear of losing what we love.

It makes me wonder how much of what I perceive as good or bad, fair or unfair, beautiful or cruel, is influenced by where I stand, whom I love, and what I fear losing.

The hawk is simply being a hawk. Yet in my eyes, it could become a villain because it threatens something I love. If I were caring for that hawk, I might look at the very same act of hunting with an entirely different emotion.

And nature continues, regardless of how I feel about it. A bird eats an insect. A hawk eats the bird. Countless living beings survive through the consumption of other living beings. What appears as tragedy from one perspective may be nourishment from another.

The same universe that gives us extraordinary beauty also contains immense suffering. There is tenderness, but there is destruction. There is the joy of being alive and the inevitable pain of losing what we love.

How do we reconcile such contradictions? And how do we live with them without losing our compassion?

I don’t believe the answer is to become indifferent. I don’t want to stop feeling sad when a tiny creature suffers. I don’t want to stop protecting my birds simply because I understand that death is inevitable. And I certainly don’t want spiritual wisdom to turn me into someone who witnesses suffering without being moved by it.

But I am beginning to recognize a difference between feeling compassion and becoming imprisoned by attachment.

The contradiction may not be something I can resolve by changing the nature of existence. What can change is the way I perceive and respond to it.

Beyond the Dualities

This is where I begin to appreciate the deeper significance of sadhana, meditation, and wisdom.

Through spiritual practice, we contemplate impermanence, detachment, equanimity, and the dualities of life. Pleasure and pain. Gain and loss. Birth and death.

I have heard these teachings so many times. I have reflected on them and understood them intellectually. Yet something as small as a fly burning on my stove was enough to disturb my heart. It made me wonder how deeply that wisdom has actually become part of my experience.

When I witness suffering, can I feel compassion without becoming overwhelmed by helplessness? Can I love something deeply without being consumed by the fear of losing it? Can I understand the hawk’s hunger while still wanting to protect the little bird?

I don’t have all the answers. But I am beginning to appreciate why spiritual wisdom cannot remain merely intellectual. It has to become part of how I experience life, especially when life confronts me with something painful.

Meditation helps me become more aware of what is happening within my own mind, to recognize love as it becomes fear, fear as it becomes anger, and attachment as it shapes my perception. Wisdom reminds me that everything I experience is changing, that nothing can remain permanent simply because I wish it to.

Perhaps true detachment is not the absence of love, but love freed from the fear of losing.

I may still want to protect the little bird. But protecting one life need not mean resenting another. Compassion may be able to embrace both, even when their needs are in conflict.

And beyond accepting these dualities lies an understanding that I find even more profound.

Vedanta speaks of one ultimate reality manifesting as this entire universe of countless names and forms. The bird, the hawk, the fly, the human being. Different bodies, different experiences, different struggles, yet from the nondual understanding, none ultimately separate from that one reality.

At one level, I see a bird being hunted by a hawk. At another, deeper level, I contemplate the same existence manifesting as both predator and prey. I find this extraordinarily beautiful, but I also recognize how difficult it is to truly experience.

The bird still struggles. The hawk still hungers. The human heart still grieves. I cannot simply dismiss suffering by saying that everything is one or that the world is an illusion.

I don’t want wisdom to take away my compassion. I want it to deepen my compassion while freeing me from the suffering that attachment creates.

I wonder whether, as sadhana deepens and the veil between ignorance and divinity grows thinner, the apparent separation between these countless forms gradually gives way to a direct experience of their underlying oneness.

The pain may still be felt, but it may no longer be experienced through the same sense of separation. What appears as opposing forces may begin to be understood as expressions of one indivisible existence.

I haven’t reached that understanding fully. There is still a distance between what I understand intellectually and what I am able to live. But this is the direction in which my spiritual journey continues.

Tomorrow morning, I will once again fill the feeders and welcome my little visitors. I will watch them eat, bathe, and fly away, and my heart will fill with the same joy. Somewhere, a hawk will be searching for its next meal. Somewhere, another tiny creature will lose its life. Creation, preservation, and destruction will continue, whether I understand them or not.

I cannot make life permanent simply because I love it. Nor can I protect every living being from suffering. But I can continue to care, learning not to let love become possessiveness, fear harden into hatred, or acceptance turn into indifference.

I don’t know if I will ever completely reconcile these contradictions. But I hope that through sadhana, meditation, and the deepening of wisdom, I will gradually learn to see beyond the separation that makes them so difficult to bear.

One existence. Countless forms. An endless play of creation, preservation, and dissolution.

The bird will still be a bird. The hawk will still be a hawk. And my heart may still ache for the suffering of one while understanding the hunger of the other.

But I hope to grow into a compassion that can embrace them both, without needing either one to be the villain.


Comments

Leave a Reply